Main      Site Guide    
Message Forum
Re: Pacifists, medics etc
Posted By: Gortman64, on host 24.205.79.56
Date: Thursday, July 4, 2002, at 10:25:54
In Reply To: Re: Pacifists, medics etc posted by Brunnen-G on Thursday, July 4, 2002, at 00:16:36:

> > OK, a pysoclogical problem with killing another man is perfectly normal and understanding. If you are a pacifist, you vould become a medic. I don't mean a doctor, I mean the guy that crawls out into the field and drags the injured guy's body back to the doctor.
>
> Maybe I'm reading too much into your posts, so if I'm wrong, I apologise in advance. But your view of military life seems to be very focused on conspicuous heroics in combat. Why else would you need to specify the above scenario? Because it sounds so much cooler and more exciting and more dangerous than just "being a doctor". To be blunt, your concept of military life seems restricted to what a sheltered teenager might pick up from action movies and his admiration for a relative who *almost* went to a real war.
>
> There's nothing wrong with this, in itself. But your own hopes and dreams aren't good reasons to suggest everybody *else* should choose this path. And you still haven't given any reasons which don't come from your personal emotions.
>
> You obviously have a strong desire for a military career, and part of that comes from the feeling that you will be serving your country. That's fine. However, you ought to think about whether idealism is what keeps individual soldiers going in a bad combat situation. I haven't been in combat but I've been in some (very loosely) similar situations, and believe me, the last thing on your mind is going to be the ideals which made you get into it originally. Maybe it works for some. But I have a feeling that if you intend to be a career soldier, you need to have some better reasons than abstract idealism, or at least some secondary ones.

I am was not giving a heroic senerio that deserves a medal. That's what the medics did. My dad said they had one of the more dangerous jobs, crawling into the battlefield and getting wounded soldiers. That was common practice during wars. I am *not* a sheltered teenage focused on conspicuos heroics in battle. I know that many men went to Vietnam and other wars, never came back, and no one ever knew who they were. I just mentioned Pops to show that I've been taught that I should go serve my country, and the military is one way, which I believe every man should do.

Replies To This Message

Post a Reply

RinkChat Username:
Password:
Email: (optional)
Subject:
Message:
Link URL: (optional)
Link Title: (optional)

Make sure you read our message forum policy before posting.