Re: Analyzing The Matrix
Grishny, on host 12.29.132.98
Tuesday, June 3, 2003, at 11:04:32
Re: Analyzing The Matrix posted by knivetsil on Monday, June 2, 2003, at 13:35:47:
> Even with other sentient programs such as the Oracle, Seraph, and the Twins? I thought they were just software.
Hrm. I suppose I didn't really mean that every *individual* has a presence in both worlds. Rather, that both the humans and the machines have a presence in both. Although who is to say that the program that is the Oracle couldn't be loaded into a machine body in the real world and dispatched to go talk with some humans? That'd be a novel way to surpass the problem of the actress' death before filming the third movie.
> But the machines are *against* Smith, aren't they? So the sentinels would have killed Bane/Smith. My hunch is that Smith still had some control over the sentinels (Remember that sentinel control was an ability of the agents). This would also explain how Neo could stop the attacking sentinels near the near of the movie, what with his connection to Smith and all.
I only have one problem with this theory. How on earth can Bane/Smith or Neo control sentinels in the Real Worlds without some form of contact with them? Neither is connected to them through the Matrix at that point, so barring telepathy, I don' t see any way it's possible, unless *they haven't actually left the Matrix*.
Several people have suggested that everything that happens after Neo walks through the Architect's door is actually still inside the Matrix, that Neo is in a pseudo real world. Someone else I know suggested that perhaps everyone is actually still plugged into the Matrix, and that the reason Neo went into a coma at the end of the movie is that he really and truly woke up!
> On another note, the "original AI" that you refer to is still the single, dominating intelligence that governs the vast majority of the machines. The machine race is like an ant colony, and the intelligence that the Architect represents is like the queen. Barring Smith, all machines and agents are controlled by this one consciousness.
I'm not sure I understand what you're saying. Do think the Artichect *is* that original AI, or do you think he is subservient to it?
Your ant colony analogy doesn't seem right to me. Ants don't rebel against the colony and do their own thing, and we seem to have a lot of that going on here. Certainly there are some instances, like the sentinels, where there are mindless drone-type robots that could all be run by one program, but it seems to me that most of the programs are autonomous. If all the software was a subset of the Master AI, the programs wouldn't be able to go off and do their own thing.
> Smith, I believe, as an individual, actually has not enhanced fighting abilities.
Oh, I agree, and that's not what I meant. By enhanced abilities, I pretty much was only referring to what was obvious in the movie, his new ability to replicate himself by absorbing other entities.
> Smith himself is also somewhat of an anomaly. He is a sentient program, like the other agents, a program that was self-aware and self-conscious. In the first movie, he was mostly subservient to the main AI. However, it becomes apparent that he has some beefs with the system ("I hate this place. This...zoo. This prison, this reality; whatever you want to call it, I can't stand it any longer."), In the Reloaded, he has rebelled aginst the system and has his own agenda.
That illustrates another of the contrasts between agents and other programs. Agents are probably unable to rebel against the system like other programs because they're dependent on it. They have no permanent presence within it. But now Smith *does* because of whatever it was Neo did to him. "You freed me" he says.
> When did Smith appear to work with the other agents? I don't remember any such instance, at least not in Reloaded.
I may be remembering it incorrectly. I'm thinking of the scene where Neo first fights the upgraded agents, then flies away. I thought after he left, Smith appeared and asked the agnets "is it done?" or something like that. I thought there was some cooperation between them going on there, but maybe I'm remembering it wrong. I need to see the film again.
> The agents, while subservient to the main AI, are still discrete beings. They and the main AI are not one and the same, and they probably do not know the Architect's main plan. They don't know about the Prophecy or the purpose of the One or what happens if the One reaches the Source. All they care about is keeping the peace, which includes finding and killing free humans and exiles. The Keymaker is an exile, and so is targeted by the agents for deletion.
That sounds right to me, but doesn't seem to jive with what you said earlier about the whole ant colony thing.
Gri"going on for hours"shny
|