Message Forum: Re: More on Novels vs. Films: Arwen

Re: More on Novels vs. Films: Arwen

Posted By: Grishny, on host 12.29.132.98
Date: Wednesday, December 18, 2002, at 08:30:11
In Reply To: Re: More on Novels vs. Films: Arwen posted by Brunnen-G on Wednesday, December 18, 2002, at 07:34:13:

> In the book (although I think it's in the final
volume), she sends him a flag and his horse,
via a group of his own men who turn up for the
battle, along with her brothers Eladan and
Elrohir. This would be the battle of Minas
Tirith, not Helm's Deep. It seems like that
would be the most obvious point for her
reappearance.

You are correct. I just finished my fifth
re-reading of the trilogy, so the events are
pretty fresh in my memory.

Gri"Well, I'm back"shny

RinkChat Username:
Password:
Email:		(optional)
Subject:
Message:	> > In the book (although I think it's in the final > volume), she sends him a flag and his horse, > via a group of his own men who turn up for the > battle, along with her brothers Eladan and > Elrohir. This would be the battle of Minas > Tirith, not Helm's Deep. It seems like that > would be the most obvious point for her > reappearance. > > You are correct. I just finished my fifth > re-reading of the trilogy, so the events are > pretty fresh in my memory. > > Gri"Well, I'm back"shny
Link URL:		(optional)
Link Title:		(optional)

Post a Reply