Main      Site Guide    
Message Forum
Re: A $100 Question Worth $125,000
Posted By: Grishny, on host 207.90.112.8
Date: Monday, March 12, 2001, at 17:30:42
In Reply To: Re: A $100 Question Worth $125,000 posted by Paul A. on Monday, March 12, 2001, at 17:13:29:

> > That seems to be a popular trend with successfull short stories in the science fiction
> > genre. Some examples I can think of are "Nightfall" and "Bicentennial Man," both
> > by Asimov.
>
> Those are different, because the novels weren't by Asimov, they're by someone else inspired by Asimov's story.
> Oh, and they're crap. :o)

I disagree. First of all, both "Nightfall" and "The Positronic Man" (the novel based on Bicentennial Man) were co-authored by Asimov and Silverburg. Secondly, I enjoyed both books, and I don't think it's because I like to read crap. I think we just have different tastes.

Grishny

Replies To This Message