Message Forum: The Best Scrooge

The Best Scrooge

Posted By: Grishny, on host 65.58.89.173
Date: Wednesday, December 4, 2002, at 19:22:02
In Reply To: Re: Quick movie question - the point posted by Quartz on Wednesday, December 4, 2002, at 16:41:15:

> Qua "Alistir Sim is TEH BETS Scrooge...

Who?

No, George C. Scott is the best Scrooge. He's just sooo good at playing mean, and then at the end of the movie when he becomes good, it's actually believable because he still has that gruff exterior on the surface overlaying the changed heart inside.

Of all the Scrooges I've seen, I'd rate them in the following order:

1. George C. Scott
2. Michael Caine
3. Albert Finney
4. Patrick Stewart
5. Scrooge McDuck

Gri"would put Bill Murray in there somewhere, but has never seen 'Scrooged' all the way through"shny

Replies To This Message

Re: The Best Scrooge - Adam Bomb - Fri, 12/6/2002, 22:33:49
- Re: The Best Scrooge - Howard - Sat, 12/7/2002, 05:20:23
Re: The Best Scrooge - Quartz - Thu, 12/5/2002, 16:47:16
- Re: The Best Scrooge - Michael - Tue, 8/12/2003, 09:24:09
- Re: The Best Scrooge - Grishny - Fri, 12/6/2002, 05:01:58
Re: The Best Scrooge - Nyperold - Wed, 12/4/2002, 20:20:42
- Re: The Best Scrooge - Bourne - Thu, 12/5/2002, 06:45:16
  - Re: The Best Scrooge - Dixie - Thu, 12/5/2002, 09:58:00
- Re: The Best Scrooge - Grishny - Thu, 12/5/2002, 04:58:04

RinkChat Username:
Password:
Email:		(optional)
Subject:
Message:	> > Qua "Alistir Sim is TEH BETS Scrooge... > > Who? > > No, George C. Scott is the best Scrooge. He's just sooo good at playing mean, and then at the end of the movie when he becomes good, it's actually believable because he still has that gruff exterior on the surface overlaying the changed heart inside. > > Of all the Scrooges I've seen, I'd rate them in the following order: > > 1. George C. Scott > 2. Michael Caine > 3. Albert Finney > 4. Patrick Stewart > 5. Scrooge McDuck > > Gri"would put Bill Murray in there somewhere, but has never seen 'Scrooged' all the way through"shny
Link URL:		(optional)
Link Title:		(optional)

Replies To This Message

Post a Reply