Main      Site Guide    
Message Forum
Re: In defense of Americans
Posted By: Don the Monkeyman, on host 24.67.84.133
Date: Tuesday, May 29, 2001, at 13:04:38
In Reply To: In defense of Americans posted by Jezzika on Monday, May 28, 2001, at 18:23:01:

> As a response to such discussions, one woman posted this. I think it's very insightful, and though it's a bit defensive in places, I liked it.

*sigh* I had to think for a bit before I decided to post this. I'm going to keep it short.

I did find some aspects of that linked post to be interesting. However, I found that the major flaw in it was its use of straw man arguments. I have never heard anyone attack US foreign policy as stupid, and certainly, the US tendency to help others in need is not a bad thing. Instead, the arguments tend to discuss things such as the average US citizen's knowledge of geography. I do not personally believe that this is a good reason to call Americans "stupid", but I don't want to go into depth on that topic right now. I think that in reality, there is a great deal of hypocrisy involved in ANY argument which calls Americans "stupid". I do not think, though, that the linked post deals with the problem in an appropriate fashion (although the post itself seems to be free from error--it just addresses the wrong issues). Perhaps some time when I am feeling a little more sure of my position and a little more comfortable with my time, I will write a post that goes into more detail on the nature of this hypocrisy, as I see it.

Don "Not right now, though" Monkey