Main      Site Guide    
Message Forum
Re: What's so cool about CTHD?
Posted By: Paul A., on host 130.95.128.51
Date: Tuesday, March 20, 2001, at 19:23:27
In Reply To: Re: What's so cool about CTHD? posted by Wolfspirit on Tuesday, March 20, 2001, at 12:03:35:

> One thing I just /don't/ understand. Anybody know why CTHD bombed so badly in Beijing and
> Shanghai?

There are two explanations I've heard:

1. Unlike Western audiences, they've seen the flying-swordsman-martial-movie thing done before in other movies.

2. Thanks to the healthy Asian pirate industry, they'd already seen the movie before it was released in cinemas.


> Apparently the Shanghainese audiences hissed and cursed at the flying scenes, which makes
> no sense. Scenes of fantasy "flying swordsmen" is standard fare for martial arts flicks, so
> what gives?

Perhaps they feel that other movies have done it better, which I can understand.

Also, CTHD is in some respects a Western-movie-trying-to-do-the-Oriental-thing rather than an Oriental movie, which is something that Oriental audiences might not appreciate.
Many people feel, perhaps with justification, that Western martial arts movies lack something that Oriental ones have.

Paul