> [problems with early Star Trek:TNG]
>
> > One of the episodes in the first season was a remake of an original series episode.
>
> Assuming that you mean "The Naked Now", I would like to point out that there is, strange as it may seem, a difference between a remake and a sequel. And "The Naked Now" is a sequel.
>
> [not-problems with Andromeda]
>
> > insects/humanoids are difficult to pull off convincingly anyway, I don't hold that aginst
> > them
>
> If we can't blame them for failing because the task was so difficult, can we blame them for attempting the task when they didn't have to?
>
> Paul

I respect that they tried to do something diffrent, they just didn't pull it off. A lot of the early TNG aliens wern't very convincing. Like the Binars, or the early version of the Ferangies, or Worf's first set of cranial ridges.

What I'm saying is Andromeda made a fairly good first episode. There is room for improvement, and after the first epsiode of every show there is room for improvement. Especially sci fi shows. I think Andromeda has the potential to develope in to a very good show.



Speed'still a die hard Trekker'ball