Main      Site Guide    
Message Forum
Re: Length of books in a series
Posted By: gabby, on host 206.64.3.139
Date: Tuesday, June 27, 2000, at 17:31:43
In Reply To: Length of books in a series posted by Ferrick on Tuesday, June 27, 2000, at 15:32:39:

> I have been wondering why it is that authors who write series of books seem to increase the length of the story with each volume. This definitely is not across the board, but two example that I am thinking of are the Jack Ryan series by Tom Clancy and the Harry Potter books.
>
> Harry Potter: Book 1, 309 pages; Book 2, 341 pages; Book 3, 435 pages.
>
> Jack Ryan: HfRO, 387 pages; PG, 540; CotK, 543; CaPD, ??; SoAF, 914 (paperback); WR, 639; DoH, 766; EO 1358 (paperback); R6, 740.
>
> I read that the newest Harry Potter if around 750 pages long! It is hard for me to believe that the fourth book in the series will be longer than the first two combined. Tom Clancy's longest book, Executive Orders, was also his worst (this is my OPINION, of course). I felt that he just wrote for the sake of writing, throwing in a lot of side plots, and then, wrapped everything up WAY too quickly with little to no suspense. His latest, and the one following EO, was shorter, tighter, and more interesting. I hope the next Harry Potter doesn't fall into this trap. I have no problems with a long book and an author shouldn't have to limit their work because of that, but taking a step back to look at whether the length is necessary or just redundant is a good thing.
>
> So, has anyone else noticed a trend like this in other series? Is there a reason for this? Is this trend in other mediums of entertainment, such as film (James Cameron) music?
>
> Ferr"is Bueller stayed home s"ick

One of my favorite series is Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn by Tad Williams. I read paperback versions of the trilogy. The first two, "The Dragonbone Chair" and "Stone of Farewell," were each in the mid-700's. The third, "To Green Angel Tower," was closer to 1600. The author had clever nicknames for the latter in the introduction; the only one I remember is "The Story That Ate My Life." He explained in the intro why in the world he wrote so lopsidedly--basically, his contract said "trilogy," and, not being Douglas Adams, he couldn't get out of it.

ga"rbage all over the house would make me cra"bby

Replies To This Message