> > > What do you think about this:
> > > In Hawaii, it is illegal for anyone under 18 to drive, even if they have a valid driver's license in another state. Comments?
> > > Howard
>
> I believe that the law is similar in NYC (although I could be wrong). It makes a lot of sense to me there - loads of traffic, crazy drivers. A higher driving age makes for fewer drivers, if nothing else. However, I'm not sure I understand the reasoning for it in Hawaii.
>
> >A 16-18 year old licensed driver from another state should be alowed to retest and obtain a Hawaiian license. This test could be more stringent than the standard test, since the driver is younger. It would, therefore, most likely only be worth it for new residents, as who would want to worry about studying and scheduling time to test during their weeklong vacation.
> >
> > Tra "just a thought" nio
>
> Well, that brings up a couple of interesting points. First of all, how would you feel as a 17 year old who's lived in Hawaii all your life, having a 16 year old move into town and they're allowed to get a licsence, but you aren't?
>

Well, I'd be sad and cry my eyes out.

> On the other hand, who's to say that a 18 year old with little driving experience is going to be a better driver than a 17 year old who moves in with a year of driving experience? Where's the line between driving experience and life experience.
>

That's the problem with every law that grants certain priveleges simply based upon someone chronological status. There are always going to be individuals who just shouldn't be driving or drinking when they're legally able to. But any other type of regulation would just be too costly to incorporate. Imagine having to evaluate the entire population as to their psychological readiness toward either of these activities. It's the "easy out". Simply draw a line, and once you cross it, you're in. It has worked adequately so far; so if it's not broke...


> So, to answer Howard's question, I have mixed feelings about all of this.
>
> Luisa


Tra "I can easily understand reasons for and against allowing them to drive; I guess that's why we vote on things like this." nio